Usability Testing is more than Testing

Posted by Dan Eastwell Wed, 21 May 2008 12:15:00 GMT

Simple usability testing as advocated by Jakob Nielsen with five users showed that user testing did not need to be an expensive procedure; products such as Morae allow 'usability labs' to be constructed from two laptops and a webcam.

This has made Usability Testing as practical and almost exclusively necessary part of the building of any interface (e.g. a simple website) or application (e.g. a website with any form of interaction)

Usability practitioners advocate testing throughout the design process, and not just as an afterthought once an application is built - this can be a simple procedure, with the most trying part being organising your five participants, but regular testing days can return rewards beyond optimising an interface for ease of use.

Get feedback

You can fairly quickly get feedback not only on how or whether your site works, but also on your users' general experience of similar sites, or real-world alternatives. How do your users normally find sign-up procedures? Are they worthwhile? Do they have trouble with so many passwords? Do they like newsletters? Are they familiar with RSS? And so on...

Incremental testing on rollouts

37 signals paved the way with progressive rollouts and testing constantly through this process allows you to fine tune your application. The danger of course is knee-jerk redesigns every time a user misses a button.

Get Evangelists

People will have volunteered for your user testing, especially if you've advertised through Craiglists or Gumtree, and you reimburse people for their time. Your test subjects will probably see this as something of a fun day out and should by the end of it be in a good mood. People love being asked their opinion, and enjoy being part of the process.

Regular testing will mean you have a constant stream of users who have not only seen your site, but have seen you and know you are keen to get things right. This will mean they're pretty likely to tell people about their fun day out and the nice people there. This can only be a good thing...

Contact with clients and creating superusers

In the same way a telephone call is better than an email, regular face-to-face meetings with your user base can lead to a positive reflection on your app/site.

Your users will be more forgiving of any future problems if they know that you're the kind of people who'll look into it, or probably are already.

Through showing people how your site works, possibly in much greater detail than they would find coming to it cold, you also get the equivalent of old school software 'training days', and a set of users who should end up knowing the workings of your site fairly well and, at best, are able to pass this knowledge on.

Regular testing, regular meetings

With all this in mind, it's probably worth conducting testing days even if you've got no significant changes to make to your site.

If you keep a database of past testees and those that you didn't have time for, you have the ability to keep in constant 'real-world' touch with your user-base.

User testing can be a very positive way of getting to know your end-users, and in a very focussed way - you have:

  • A database of possible testers
  • A database of people who know your site and can comment on future change
  • A set of site evangelists
  • Some possible future superusers

Your users:

  • Have a more positive view of your site and it's working
  • Become more likely to give you feedback normally
  • View you not just a faceless frustrationas, but as 'human'.

Posted in , , , , ,  | Tags , , , , ,  | no comments | no trackbacks

Site interaction beyond the website

Posted by Dan Eastwell Fri, 16 May 2008 13:49:07 GMT

I can happily watch Vimeo videos such as the one illustrated below, within my feed reader, google reader

screenshot of vimeo interface within a feed reader

The great thing is, not only is can I watch the embedded flash movie, I also have the other site's interface within my reader, in that I can favourite the video. When I return to the vimeo site, my favourite has been added.

Posted in ,  | 2 comments | no trackbacks

User Centered Design Process

Posted by Dan Eastwell Tue, 13 May 2008 09:56:00 GMT

Here's a short presentation on User Centered Design with examples of user experience and information architecture I've worked on.

It's not definitive, but reflects the process I've used in the past - hopefully it might be of some use!

A roadmap of User Centered Design

Posted in , ,  | Tags , , , , , , , , ,  | no comments | no trackbacks

What is a Wireframe?

Posted by Dan Eastwell Sat, 10 May 2008 12:00:00 GMT

James: question for you

what is a wireframe?

Me: well, there, good question

a wireframe is essentially a prototype

it can take many forms

I will provide you with examples

sent at 2:55 pm on wednesday

A set of blueprints for a website made in excel will do for a wireframe

as will something jazzy like this prototype http://test2.danieleastwell.co.uk/scholastic/index.html

you will note the grey areas for unknown content etc and the fact it is mostly static.

however, you could do exactly the same thing with just layout css, rather than anything better

or you could do it all on paper

sent at 3:00 pm on wednesday

James: ah I see

so its a static html version of a dynamic site

Me: not necessarily

it could have no styling

or not be in html

James: so its quite a vague term then

Me: yeah, just like 'prototype'

it could be a set of visio or excel files

I like to prototype in html and css as I find it easy, but I find that I also need some design styleguides

the draw back to doing it that way is you get stuck in the 'how' and don't concentrate on the 'what it does'

I prefer paper.

it's a lot quicker and you don't mind making revisions

James: yeah I tend to plan stuff on paper

Me: you can also scan drawings in and plop them in html if you just need to change something on only one bit

sent at 3:06 pm on wednesday

Me: here's an example of a paper prototype

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ppnRQD06ggY

actually, here's a much much better one.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c4-A-9hGn0U

that's genius. you can tell exaclty what the application is going to do, without having to have it built

you could say they used simple video editing instead of html to wireframe it

I suppose also, though that that's a prototype - a wireframe is more formal and static and has details of what each part of the page contains and does

although some people call that a 'functional spec'

sent at 3:10 pm on wednesday

James: its some dude wandering around an office

ah I see

Me: are you watching the second one?

the 'ciao'?

you really get a feel for what the app will do.

James: yes

yeah pretty clever

Me: also, very simple. saves a lot of time in app development to get your protoypes right.

and in a very skewed way that vid is a 'wireframe' as it tells you 'what it does'

(not 'how it works' or 'what it will look like')

sent at 3:14 pm on wednesday

Me: I might put this chat on my blog. seems like a fairly useful bit of an introduction...

(to wireframing)

Posted in , ,  | Tags , , , , , , ,  | 2 comments | no trackbacks

Why I won't work on another campaign microsite

Posted by Dan Eastwell Tue, 20 Nov 2007 17:14:00 GMT

or why I won't, until the money runs out...

Jeffrey Zeldman maintains his position as the spokesman for the progenitors of web design and web development in the latest issue of A List Apart by stating that even in this late stage of the web, that web design is poorly understood.

Read more...

Posted in , , ,  | Tags , , , ,  | no comments | no trackbacks

New Portfolio Articles

Posted by Dan Eastwell Sat, 07 Apr 2007 20:08:00 GMT

A bit of shameless self promotion, here, but I've made the effort, so why not let people know?

There's a few new articles on my main site:

Boots Expert: Progressive enhancement: Javascript enhancement to pages, and CSS systems analysis, to tight accessibility requirements.

This project went live at the end of last week, and I'm fairly proud of how the project went and the outcomes. The site is very accessible and has been well reviewed and tested. I think the design is great (not my work!) and I'm happy with the soundness of the XHTML and the CSS, especially, which I think has been nicely modularised.

Energy Saving Trust: Ajax modules: Reskin work on existing coldfusion-driven modules, creating javascript to enhance the look of the output code. Ajax modules written to enhance HTML forms.

Design Council: Complex Modular Site: A complex modular site using transparencies, and intricate CSS structure.

I worked on this last year and now the site is live. This was a large project with many templates necessary to match the designs, it's lead me to think a lot about the status of interface architecture for the web (or CSS/XHTML, if you will…) as a discipline requiring the same level of forethought as any other software-based discipline, when dealing with projects with any level of scale or complexity.

Posted in , , , , , ,  | no comments | no trackbacks

Blogging from your Mobile

Posted by Dan Eastwell Sat, 25 Nov 2006 10:20:00 GMT

Being a showy know-it-all, I decided to prove how good opera mini was to my friends in the pub by updating my blog.

James had noticed a typo on my BBC article, which I thought would be easy to fix.

That was the case, but the textarea on either my phone or opera mini was too small to keep the whole article in, so the BBC article is neatly truncated.

Being the clever know-it-all I am, I didn't keep a back up, so the article, for what it's worth is lost forever..!

Posted in  | 2 comments | 1 trackback

Back on dial-up: the problem with large page weights

Posted by Dan Eastwell Tue, 04 Jul 2006 18:17:00 GMT

Another post in what is becoming a series concerning how us designers and developers have forgotten what it’s like being hampered by either older or lower spec technology or a lack of computer use experience.

I’m posting this in a wifi enabled café, but the connection we have at our rented place is dial-up on a fairly old PC. It's an extremely frustrating experience trying to view pages at a download speed of 40kbps.

It’s another experience to bear in mind when developing, and being aware that even though broadband use in the UK is rising that there still remains approximately 40% of users who don’t use broadband. And that’s according to a site devoted to promoting investment in the UK.

It might be worth 'investing' in slow machine, with a throttled connection, in order to understand the sense of doom you feel when you realise that you have to open a 300kb PDF file.

Posted in ,  | no comments | no trackbacks

The Problem with Validation

Posted by Dan Eastwell Wed, 21 Jun 2006 12:46:50 GMT

It’s been a long struggle, but finally accessible, and by extension valid, web pages are the norm, with innaccessible HTML and CSS banished to the last millenium

However, as with all goals, there can be the tendency for them to go too far and for the means to become more important than the means.

As a result, there’s a tendency to treat the WCAG as rules, rather than the guidelines they are.

The guidelines are littered with 'where appropriate's 'may's and 'until user agent's, thus you can’t, and really shouldn’t treat them as normative, let alone as pseudo-legal, documents

I've not been on the sharp end of this in any great way, yet, but it would be odd to not get a sign-off on a project just because of a spurious validation error. This is especially significant as validators don't necessarily come up with the same results each time.

Posted in , , , ,  | no comments | 1 trackback

Usability, the eldery and internet first-timers

Posted by Dan Eastwell Mon, 19 Jun 2006 08:21:00 GMT

Everyone knows what a hyperlink looks like, don't they? Everyone knows what the submit button looks like and where it will be, surely, by now?

I'm afraid I've been guilty of making similar assumptions: that a hyperlink nowadays is just 'different somehow' to normal text, that a submit button is 'probably on the bottom right'.

This weekend was my Grandad's 90th birthday, and my family clubbed together to get him a PC, for shopping online and sending emails to family overseas.

I gave him what I thought would be a quick once over, by giving him the task of finding out what time my train would leave, using National Rail.

It was a real eye-opener.

Read more...

Posted in , ,  | no comments | no trackbacks